eseoulpost
DomesticSocial affairs
Supreme Court rules religious belief valid reason for refusing mandatory military service
min  |  min
폰트키우기 폰트줄이기 프린트하기 메일보내기 신고하기
승인 2018.11.01  
트위터 페이스북 미투데이 요즘 네이버 구글 msn
   
 

The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that religious and conscientious beliefs are to be considered valid reasons for refusing the military service mandate, overturning its decision from 14 years ago.

In a 9-4 vote, the full bench led by Chief Justice Kim Meong-su delivered the decision and ordered an appellate court to retry the case of Oh Seung-hun, effectively stating that the appellant should be cleared of the conviction.

Thursday's ruling potentially allows for 227 other similar cases pending at the top court and some 930 conscientious objectors currently on trial in Korea to avoid criminal convictions for disobeying the mandate and to replace their duties with alternative services.

"Punishing (conscientious objectors) for refusing the conscription on grounds of religious faith, in others words, freedom of conscience, is deemed an excessive constraint to an individual's freedom of conscience ... and goes against democracy that stands for tolerance of minorities," the court ruled.

The latest ruling follows the Constitutional Court's June 28 ruling that recognized for the first time the need for alternative service for conscientious objectors.

Oh has been sentenced to 18 months in prison for refusing to do his military duty, which applies to all able-bodied men in the country. He has argued he is a Jehovah's Witness and serving in the Army is against his religious faith.

"This verdict was possible thanks to the patience of my predecessors and colleagues totaling some 20,000 people," Oh told reporters. "I hope there will also be forward-looking and positive rulings in about 930 pending cases too."

   Oh said he's well-aware of concerns that conscientious objection could be abused as a means to dodge military service and he will try to carry out alternative service in a sincere manner so as to dispel such concerns.

The lower trial courts have increasingly handed down not-guilty verdicts for conscientious objectors since the first ruling in 2016.

The current Military Service Act stipulates that objectors face up to three years in prison. Since the 1950s, about 19,000 conscientious objectors have been arrested and served time, mostly 18 months in jail.

In all three past hearings, the top court ruled in favor of the law and found the defendant guilty. The court had cited that military obligation takes precedence over individual freedom of conscience, as the two Koreas are technically at war, since the 1950-53 Korean War ended in a truce and not a peace treaty. Thursday's ruling reversed these decisions.

Public hearings have been held on the issue since the latest Constitutional Court's ruling. Experts and lawmakers are leaning toward the idea of working at public institutions, such as state prisons or fire stations, for twice the length of the term.

 

< 저작권자 © eseoulpost 무단전재 및 재배포금지 >
폰트키우기 폰트줄이기 프린트하기 메일보내기 신고하기
트위터 페이스북 미투데이 요즘 네이버 구글 msn 뒤로가기 위로가기
이 기사에 대한 댓글 이야기 (0)
자동등록방지용 코드를 입력하세요!   
확인
- 200자까지 쓰실 수 있습니다. (현재 0 byte / 최대 400byte)
- 욕설등 인신공격성 글은 삭제 합니다. [운영원칙]
이 기사에 대한 댓글 이야기 (0)
Most Read
1
Sharjah maintains strong presence on world cultural scene
2
Sharjah, Barcelona strengthening healthcare, education cooperation
3
Mohamed bin Zayed receives head of US delegation to Special Olympics World Games
4
UNHCR’s Grandi expresses shock following New Zealand’s massacre of innocent worshippers
5
New permanent public artworks in Abu Dhabi to deliver lasting legacy of inclusion
6
First Lady of the Dominican Republic visits Wahat Al Karama
7
UAE Unified football team seal first victory at World Games Abu Dhabi with 4-0 win over South Africa
8
Mohamed bin Zayed, Liberian President explore prospects of joint cooperation
9
Fatima directs formation of 'Mothers of People of Determination Association'
10
Yonhap files complaint against News1 over unlawful distribution of Rodong Sinmun content
Photo News Green Biz
Restoration of nature requires actions of many :Al Zeyoudi
Restoration of nature requires act...
min
Al Zeyoudi to head UAE delegation to upcoming Global Climate Action Summit in California
Al Zeyoudi to head UAE delegation ...
min
Plastic wastes from Korea legal: MisOr ecozone exec
Plastic wastes from Korea legal: M...
min
Spotlight on UAE's environmental efforts at Urban Sustainability Week
Spotlight on UAE's environmental e...
min
DEWA invites customers to take up Shams Dubai to generate onsite solar power
DEWA invites customers to take up ...
min
Photo News Sports
Over 500 Paralympic athletes to compete in IWAS World Games 2019 on Sunday in Sharjah
Over 500 Paralympic athletes to co...
min
New York City FC announces preseason in Abu Dhabi
New York City FC announces preseas...
min
AFC Asian Cup UAE 2019
AFC Asian Cup UAE 2019
min
VP crowns Abdullah Al Marri winner of Mohammed Bin Rashid Endurance Cup
VP crowns Abdullah Al Marri winner...
min
Welcome to the land of Zayed, land of tolerance, Nahyan bin Zayed tells 2019 AFC Asian Cup teams
Welcome to the land of Zayed, land...
min
World Taekwondo Grand-Prix Final launched in Fujairah
World Taekwondo Grand-Prix Final l...
min
Koreas agree to formally inform IOC of intent to co-host 2032 Olympics
Koreas agree to formally inform IO...
min
Etisalat sponsors UAE Paralympics at Asian Para Games
Etisalat sponsors UAE Paralympics ...
min
Photo News World
Over 500 Paralympic athletes to compete in IWAS World Games 2019 on Sunday in Sharjah
Over 500 Paralympic athletes to co...
min
New York City FC announces preseason in Abu Dhabi
New York City FC announces preseas...
min
AFC Asian Cup UAE 2019
AFC Asian Cup UAE 2019
min
VP crowns Abdullah Al Marri winner of Mohammed Bin Rashid Endurance Cup
VP crowns Abdullah Al Marri winner...
min
Welcome to the land of Zayed, land of tolerance, Nahyan bin Zayed tells 2019 AFC Asian Cup teams
Welcome to the land of Zayed, land...
min
World Taekwondo Grand-Prix Final launched in Fujairah
World Taekwondo Grand-Prix Final l...
min
Koreas agree to formally inform IOC of intent to co-host 2032 Olympics
Koreas agree to formally inform IO...
min
Etisalat sponsors UAE Paralympics at Asian Para Games
Etisalat sponsors UAE Paralympics ...
min
Photo News Opinion
S. Korea will strengthen income-led growth policy after making changes: finance minister
S. Korea will strengthen income-le...
min
PyeongChang Olympic facilities to be turned into nat'l archives, training center
PyeongChang Olympic facilities to ...
min
Ex-Prime Minister Hwang elected new chief of main opposition party
Ex-Prime Minister Hwang elected ne...
min
Samsung chief's attendance at Samsung Elec board meeting drawing focus
Samsung chief's attendance at Sams...
min
President Moon appoints new head of Seoul National University
President Moon appoints new head o...
min
President reaffirms efforts to build 'inclusive' nation
President reaffirms efforts to bui...
min
Moon blasts opposition lawmakers for denying 1980 democracy movement
Moon blasts opposition lawmakers f...
min
Presidential consultative body to hold discussion on inter-Korean economic cooperation
Presidential consultative body to ...
min
Newspaper AboutNews ReportAdvertiseComplaintsPrivacy PolicyJuvenile protectionRejection of E-mail Collection
Gangnam-gu, Teheran 52 street in Tehran Bldg, 616(Yeoksam-dong)  |  Main Phone: 02) 563-0604  |  Fax: 02) 538-5665
Chairman : jeong-woo Lee  |  Advisor : byung-il Min  |  Publisher: jae-mo Kah  |  Editors: il-hong Kim
Registration Number 1928 Seoul ah  |  eseoulpost.com / eseoulpost.net / Global Korea.,Ltd
Copyright © 2011 eseoulpost. All rights reserved. mail to jaemokah@daum.com , kih10kr@empas.com/ www.globalkorea.info
arabafrica.net / UAE Interract / Emirtes News Agency(WAM)/ http://wam.org.ae / www.uaeinteract.com