eseoulpost
DomesticPolitics
Moon-Trump leadership likely to ensure alliance despite thorny issues: U.S. experts
min  |  min
폰트키우기 폰트줄이기 프린트하기 메일보내기 신고하기
승인 2017.05.10  
트위터 페이스북 미투데이 요즘 네이버 구글 msn
   

WASHINGTON, May 9 (Yonhap) -- A series of thorny issues will test the Korea-U.S. alliance under the leadership of South Korea's new President Moon Jae-in and U.S. President Donald Trump, but the two leaders, despite their seeming differences on North Korea and other issues, are expected to keep the strong ties largely intact, U.S. experts said.
The experts also said it's very important for Moon to hold an early meeting with Trump.
"There are clearly many concerns on both sides about the future of the U.S.-ROK relationship under the combined leadership of Mr. Moon Jae-in and President Donald Trump. Those concerns center around both substance and style, with echoes of the Roh Moo-hyun-George W. Bush difficult relations very much in people's minds," Alan Romberg, a distinguished fellow at the Stimson Center, told Yonhap News Agency.
He was referring to the often-tense relations between the two countries when late former President Roh and former U.S. President George W. Bush were in office in the early 2000s. Moon, a longtime friend of Roh, served as his presidential chief of staff.

Moon's election means that liberals have retaken power after nearly a decade of conservative rule. Liberals in South Korea are known for espousing a softer approach to North Korea and a foreign policy more independent of the U.S. These could be at odds with Washington.

South Korea's new President Moon Jae-in (Yonhap)South Korea's new President Moon Jae-in (Yonhap)

Potentially contentious issues facing the two countries will mainly be about how to deal with North Korea; how to share the cost of joint defense against North Korea, including the deployment of the U.S. THAAD missile defense system; and the free trade agreement, experts said.

"Will President Moon adopt a soft attitude toward the North that will let Kim Jong-un 'off the hook' with regard to denuclearization? ... Will President Trump go beyond simply calling for harsher sanctions in the event of an ICBM launch or another nuclear test and ratchet up military pressure that will trigger conflict?" Romberg said.
"Even though THAAD is operational, will Moon suspend its operation and possibly kill the program in order to ease pressure from China, thereby weakening defense against North Korea? Will the U.S. insist that, whether the ROK directly pays for THAAD or not, Seoul must pick up a substantially greater share of the costs of U.S. deployments in Korea?" he said.
"Along with issues related to the future of the KORUS FTA, these are extremely consequential matters that Moon and Trump will have to manage well if the alliance is to remain vital and effective," the expert said.
Romberg said it's important for Moon not to repeat Roh's early tendency to establish himself as a "neutral mediator" or "balancer" between the U.S. and China. That's one of the main points that some Americans have concerns about, he said.
Moon, however, has shown he'll be different, Romberg said.
"Clearly his tendency will be toward more engagement with the North, but, at least recently, he has been careful to cast his policies as grounded in a strong alliance with the United States," he said. "He has indicated he wants to meet early with President Trump, and that will be important so that the two of them can not only avoid surprises but also coordinate and agree as much as possible on the next steps."
   Trump has also shown that despite his "outbursts" complicating the situation, he is quite capable of reversing course when he is persuaded it's in his or the country's interest to do so, and indeed Trump's record so far is one of backing off of positions that go too far and settling for policies that make more sense, the expert said.
"A good first meeting between Moon and Trump could do much to ensure continuing close coordination and collaboration in the future. So for now, both sides need to aim to produce a successful U.S.-ROK summit early on, paying attention both to substance but also to arrangements for the meeting that will facilitate their getting to know and appreciate one another as colleagues, partners and friends over the crucial period ahead," he said.
Robert Manning, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, also said the alliance will likely remain firm even though there could be some tensions over contentious issues.
"I think the US-ROK alliance is in good shape. Unless events create a difficult situation, such as instability in the North that could lead to differences, I suspect the US-ROK alliance will not be significantly altered or challenged by a Moon administration," he said.
He said that tensions could break out when the two countries negotiate a new agreement on how to share the cost of stationing 28,500 American troops in South Korea as Trump is sure to demand the ally pay its share.
Also troublesome could be Moon's proposal to reopen the now-shuttered joint industrial complex in the North Korean city of Kaesong or the suspended tourism program to the North's scenic Mount Kumgang because such moves will undermine the U.S. campaign to put more pressure on Pyongyang, Manning said.
"However, if Moon linked Kaesong and Mt. Kumgang tourism to a North Korea moratorium on missile and nuclear weapons testing and a willingness to put its nukes back on the table to restart six-party diplomacy, that might be more arguable," he said.
Other conciliatory measures that Moon could take and would also be helpful to the U.S. policy include opening a channel of communication with the North to reduce risk and misunderstanding, as well as people-to-people measures, such as sports and cultural exchanges, he said.
The THAAD deployment is another contentious issue, he said.
"If Moon tries to undo the deal on THAAD, that would cause problems. However, if the U.S. tries to change the deal, the basis on which it is deployed, and demand that the ROK pay for deployment, beyond the land and infrastructure, Moon would have a good excuse to cancel it, ask the National Assembly to pass legislation to that effect," Manning said.
"But the ROK needs more missile defense to deal with North Korea, not less. I'm concerned about Trump's remarks because alliances are based on trust, and the word of the U.S. must mean something," he said, referring to Trump's recent demand that Seoul should pay for THAAD.
Asked if Moon would have good chemistry with Trump, the expert said, "Personality-wise Moon comes from a very different background than Trump. Perhaps the severity of the North Korea problem could help to create a bond."
   Jonathan Pollack, Korea studies chair at the Brookings Institution, said the U.S. should be attentive to South Korea's views, even though there may be some areas of real differences with the Moon administration.
"This may be a case where President Trump should listen carefully to what President Moon has to say, not immediately reject it simply because it may seem at cross-purposes to the U.S.," Pollack said during a media conference call briefing.
Moon and Trump should also have an early first face-to-face meeting, he said.
"As we know, Korea has been hobbled by its political crisis that has stretched out over a number of months and quite legitimately, who would President Trump have talked to?" Pollack said.
"I think it would be very appropriate at this point for first, an immediate phone call if that has not already occurred but more a very early scheduling of a face-to-face meeting which most likely would involve President Moon traveling to the U.S.," he said. "There needs to be the establishment of a personal relationship here, something where you can have very candid discussions in private."

< 저작권자 © eseoulpost 무단전재 및 재배포금지 >
폰트키우기 폰트줄이기 프린트하기 메일보내기 신고하기
트위터 페이스북 미투데이 요즘 네이버 구글 msn 뒤로가기 위로가기
이 기사에 대한 댓글 이야기 (0)
자동등록방지용 코드를 입력하세요!   
확인
- 200자까지 쓰실 수 있습니다. (현재 0 byte / 최대 400byte)
- 욕설등 인신공격성 글은 삭제 합니다. [운영원칙]
이 기사에 대한 댓글 이야기 (0)
Most Read
1
Jordan Independence Day observed in gala reception at Hotel Shilla in Seoul on May 22
2
Abdullah bin Zayed hails Arab leaders' resolve to combat extremism and terrorism
3
Mohamed bin Zayed heads UAE delegation to GCC-US Summit
4
Arab-Islamic-American Summit kicks off in Riyadh
5
Annual 'Balikatan' bolsters bond between PHL, US forces: AFP chief
6
Global platform for smart & sustainable cities to be launched by World Green Economy Organisation (WGEO) in Seoul on May 23
7
Global platform for smart & sustainable cities officially launched in Seoul
8
China-ASEAN senior officials finish COC draft framework
9
Tsai sees herself as a leader with the will to carry out reforms
10
China, PHL tackle contentious South China Sea issues in friendly dialogue
Photo News Green Biz
Masdar City Free Zone showcases growth at Global Manufacturing and Industrialisation Summit 2017
Masdar City Free Zone showcases gr...
min
Environment and Protected Areas Authority in Sharjah prepares to mark Earth Hour
Environment and Protected Areas Au...
min
UAE joins world in marking Earth Hour on 25th March
UAE joins world in marking Earth H...
min
UAE Minister of Foreign Affairs inspects progress at Barakah nuclear power plant
UAE Minister of Foreign Affairs in...
min
EAD Secretary-General statement on 20th UAE National Environment Day
EAD Secretary-General statement on...
min
Photo News Sports
Flag of 2019 Special Olympics World Games handed over to UAE
Flag of 2019 Special Olympics Worl...
mij
Fujairah Crown Prince donates US$100,000 to Taekwondo Humanitarian Foundation
Fujairah Crown Prince donates US$1...
min
Winners of 2017 FIDE World Chess Sharjah Grand Prix awarded at closing ceremony
Winners of 2017 FIDE World Chess S...
min
(Winter Asiad) S. Korea grabs silver in men's hockey
(Winter Asiad) S. Korea grabs silv...
min
Mohammed bin Rashid witnesses Dubai International Cycling Tour stage
Mohammed bin Rashid witnesses Duba...
min
Abu Dhabi to host 2019 Special Olympics World Games, organisers make official announcement
Abu Dhabi to host 2019 Special Oly...
min
S. Korean golfer Chun In-gee happy to achieve 2016 goals
S. Korean golfer Chun In-gee happy...
min
Fatima bint Mubarak Ladies Open takes flight as golf stars land in Abu Dhabi
Fatima bint Mubarak Ladies Open ta...
min
Photo News World
Flag of 2019 Special Olympics World Games handed over to UAE
Flag of 2019 Special Olympics Worl...
mij
Fujairah Crown Prince donates US$100,000 to Taekwondo Humanitarian Foundation
Fujairah Crown Prince donates US$1...
min
Winners of 2017 FIDE World Chess Sharjah Grand Prix awarded at closing ceremony
Winners of 2017 FIDE World Chess S...
min
(Winter Asiad) S. Korea grabs silver in men's hockey
(Winter Asiad) S. Korea grabs silv...
min
Mohammed bin Rashid witnesses Dubai International Cycling Tour stage
Mohammed bin Rashid witnesses Duba...
min
Abu Dhabi to host 2019 Special Olympics World Games, organisers make official announcement
Abu Dhabi to host 2019 Special Oly...
min
S. Korean golfer Chun In-gee happy to achieve 2016 goals
S. Korean golfer Chun In-gee happy...
min
Fatima bint Mubarak Ladies Open takes flight as golf stars land in Abu Dhabi
Fatima bint Mubarak Ladies Open ta...
min
Photo News Opinion
Moon reaffirms campaign pledge to complete constitutional revision by June next year
Moon reaffirms campaign pledge to ...
min
President Moon names chief of staff, nominates prime minister
President Moon names chief of staf...
min
Ex-student activist tapped as Moon's chief of staff
Ex-student activist tapped as Moon...
min
Moon sworn in as S. Korea's 19th president
Moon sworn in as S. Korea's 19th p...
min
Moon-Trump leadership likely to ensure alliance despite thorny issues: U.S. experts
Moon-Trump leadership likely to en...
min
White House: Trump looks forward to meeting with Moon
White House: Trump looks forward t...
min
Moon claims election victory, vows to become proud president
Moon claims election victory, vows...
min
N. Korea calls for end to confrontation on eve of election in S. Korea
N. Korea calls for end to confront...
min
Newspaper AboutNews ReportAdvertiseComplaintsPrivacy PolicyJuvenile protectionRejection of E-mail Collection
Gangnam-gu, Teheran 52 street in Tehran Bldg, 616(Yeoksam-dong)  |  Main Phone: 02) 563-0604  |  Fax: 02) 538-5665
Chairman : jeong-woo Lee  |  Advisor : byung-il Min  |  Publisher: jae-mo Kah  |  Editors: il-hong Kim
Registration Number 1928 Seoul ah  |  eseoulpost.com / eseoulpost.net / Global Korea.,Ltd
Copyright © 2011 eseoulpost. All rights reserved. mail to jaemokah@daum.com , kih10kr@empas.com/ www.globalkorea.info
arabafrica.net / UAE Interract / Emirtes News Agency(WAM)/ http://wam.org.ae / www.uaeinteract.com